11

6

There are loads of 'FAIL', 'Bloopers', 'bad experience' and similar sites out there that cataglogue all the crap that is produced - and they are easy to populate.

There are sites that provide good experience 'patterns' out there - which are useful.

But Is there a good site that catalogues and rates good sites in terms of UI and UX? (note I made one in 2001 but it never really got of the ground)

....and what is the best UI you've ever used? AND WHY (specifically what part of the interface/experience is good)...

flag
rant about the poor ones at uxexchange.com/questions/1390/… – Jon Dodd Jan 18 at 11:18

25 Answers

15

As Edward Tufte said "No matter how good your interface is, less of it is better" so my vote goes to the extremely unobtrusive Dropbox.app

link|flag
Definitely agree! – Philip Morton Jan 18 at 22:44
I agree - the best interface is the invisible one – Jon Dodd Jan 19 at 9:52
+1 It's innovation on a very different scale. – ThomPete Jan 19 at 13:14
1 
I'm a big fan of Dropbox. I love the fact that I can use it without thinking about the fact that it's tere. It's even better now that I can add files as favorites and have access them offline on my iPhone. – Jeff Van Campen Jan 20 at 11:40
I agree, I also do think that Dropbox is a really great app. I was also impressed by the easy installation process. – Gabriel Svennerberg Feb 21 at 21:56
7

While not a site, but a desktop app, I like Picasa very much. Its slick interface, intutive functions are great even for the novice user.

link|flag
+1 Picasa is good it make photo editing easy. Even with the defaults. – Matt Goddard Jan 18 at 14:14
I've never used desktop version so I'll try just to feel this experience. As a photo storage I prefer Flickr =) – Kostya Jan 18 at 14:34
Love Picasa. Brilliant App. – Glen Lipka Jan 18 at 18:49
I love picassa too - and a few years ago the zooming design was truely new and inspiring – Jon Dodd Jan 19 at 9:49
7

I've been consistently impressed by Tweetie 2 for the iPhone.

It's easy to use right from the start, but also provides a number of useful features (such as pulling down to refresh your tweet stream and pulling down to see a tweet you're replying to) for intermediate users. These features are designed in such a way that they are discoverable as you use the application more frequently.

link|flag
all though Tweetie 2 looses some points for Direct Messaging - I reckon it's much more difficult than it should be and doesn't account for typical (for me at least) usage flow – Leisa Reichelt Jan 19 at 11:15
Actually, Tweetie 2 introduces some lovely UI enhancements that Apple would do well to adopt (e.g changing the swipe behaviour to reveal more options) – Alastair J Jan 19 at 16:52
Leisa, I agree: not being able to refresh Direct Messages seems like an oversight. The one other gotcha (at least for me) is viewing a single contact's tweets. I expect to see a list of tweets when I select a contact. Instead I see their profile page and have to select "### Tweets." It took me a while to find. Nevertheless, after trying a number of iPhone Twitter applications, Tweetie 2 seems to be the most enjoyable to use. This may no longer be true, since I haven't reviewed iPhone Twitter apps in several months now. – Jeff Van Campen Jan 20 at 12:02
5

I have just started using Delicious Library and have been impressed with its interface.

To add a book or DVD or whatever you just hold the barcode up to your webcam and it automatically scans it, looks up the info (on Amazon), downloads its info, reads out loud the name, and displays its image on a virtual shelf. So you can make a database record of your books and other stuff just by holding each one up to the webcam.

link|flag
Damn you, now I want a mac. – Lisa Daske Feb 1 at 14:06
4

Hands down - Google.com

link|flag
ok - but exactly why? – Jon Dodd Jan 21 at 10:29
4

Actually I think the best thing ever to happen to me was

Quicksilver

alt text

So simple yet so incredibly powerful

It's a return to the CLI but what a return it is.

link|flag
To me, it's GNOME Do :) – Allan Caeg Feb 1 at 3:29
Hrm -- I might have to disagree here. Compared to Launchbar, QuickSilver always seemed harder to use and get going. – Alastair J Feb 2 at 16:33
Gnome-Do, Quicksilver, and Launchy are all wonderful in this way. – sgnewson Jul 26 at 10:46
3

I would say Time Machine.

alt text

When it's backing your system up, the UI is as minimum as possible and never gets in your way. It's easy to forget that it's there at all.

When you're recovering data, it provides an understandable metaphor, uses straightforward controls and hides a lot of complexity.

link|flag
Having done tape-based recoveries years ago, I whole-heartedly agree with this. Recovering a single file with Time Machine works exactly as you'd expect it to. And recovering your system is almost as easy. – Jeff Van Campen Jan 20 at 11:43
Yeah, Time Machine is effortless (nearly). I've not had cause to use it to "save my bacon", but it certainly has a beautiful 2.5D UI. – Alastair J Jan 22 at 13:18
It's saved my bacon twice now! – Philip Morton Jan 22 at 13:48
3

Wordpress is my favorite program. Superb from top to bottom.

Some close runner-ups:

  1. Tableau (Gorgeous)
  2. ExtJS (A platform for developing UI, but it's awesome nonetheless)
  3. Balsamiq (Love using this tool)
  4. Picasa (mentioned already)
link|flag
Really? You think WordPress is that good? – Nathanael Boehm Jan 19 at 11:27
1 
A couple of years ago I did a review of a few light-weight CMSs and blogging platforms for a client. WordPress, while not perfect, was the only one I was comfortable putting in front of the client's less-than-tech-savvy audience. Things have changed a bit since then (Perch and the Drupal 7 User Experience project come to mind), but I think WordPress deserves a lot of credit for their efforts to make an complex system easier to use. – Jeff Van Campen Jan 20 at 11:59
In 1996, I wrote each day a little thing sorta like a blog. I did the whole thing in HTML by hand. How far we have come in just 15 years. :) Seriously though, I've used lots of other CMS systems. The plugins, the structure, the attention to detail, the community...Wordpress is a superb application. – Glen Lipka Jan 20 at 18:48
Hmmm. I think the WP UI is fairly good now, but it still seems too cluttered and complicated for typical use. – Bennett McElwee Feb 15 at 1:56
3

The best user interface could also be nominated as the worst: the emacs editor. It's an artifact of the future-past, the editor a sci-fi film from the 1980s might imagine to exist a century in the future.

Emacs' interaction design centers largely on keyboard -- many adherents never touch the mouse in normal use. Its user interface is virtually none at all -- one line at the bottom of the screen for commands and messages and another for the status bar.

This minimalist-maximalist approach gives it a near-infinite feature set with no UI bloat. (There's nothing to bloat.) In 16 years of use I've probably drawn on one-third of its functionality. But I do have some favorites: to cut a rectangular block from the interior of your selection, hit ^x,r,k. To swap two letters, hit ^t; to swap two words, hit alt-t. Alt-/ takes the partial word beneath the cursor and intelligently autocompletes it from the words in all open documents (so a function name like 'validate_duplicate_line_items' can take as few as four or five keystrokes).

The genius of emacs lies in its collection of 'modes', bundles of code that adjust the editor's behavior for the type of file you're editing. Open an html file and the editor will indent and outdent automatically, do syntax highlighting, and enable keystrokes to let you open the current file in a browser or push it to a remote machine. Sure, Dreamweaver and Coda both let you do this -- but those can't provide equivalent functionality (and with the same perfect interface) for plain text, ruby scripts, config files, server log browsing or a hundred others.

Emacs is eminently configurable and extensible: the editor is written in a fast, powerful version of the Lisp programming language. Modes and other customizations don't require some second-class scripting addon -- they use the same lisp language and draw on extensive 'hooks' into the code to alter even core behavior succinctly and safely. Emacs contains a fully-featured web browser, terminal client, mail reader, even a psychiatrist. (Detractors hold that emacs is the perfect operating system, lacking only a decent text editor).

Its downsides are significant. Since its core functions have remained unchanged for three decades, its keystrokes predate all modern conventions: use "^x,f" to open a file, "^k" to cut a line and "^w" to cut a selection of text. Niceties such as dropdown-menus, mouse interactions and context help do exist, but often feel out of place and clumsy. Its look and feel breaks from all modern operating systems.

If you're willing to summit its himalayan learning curve, however, emacs becomes an extension of your fingertips, a frictionless channel from idea into form.

link|flag
nice reply - yes I remember using emacs in the early 90s - never got beyond the basics but then again I have the memory of a fish and struggle doing ninja keyboard moves. I have seen it used amazingly though by an officianado - so yes it is the best and worst simultaneously... perhaps approaching (just in a small way) jef raskins humane interface - but not quite (modes!, files etc.) - I'm not sure the canon cat did either though – Jon Dodd Jan 24 at 10:37
I'd say Vim... :P – sgnewson Jul 26 at 10:47
2

I'm a big fan of (on the desktop):

Lightroom works the way I work as a photographer, so it just gels. The Lightroom team have really done their homework, and it shows.

Espresso just gets out of the way when I'm putting together code and prototypes, and this is a big win.

link|flag
2

adding one of my own - the Wii interface (and controllers) - OK some bits stink a bit but many of the features are pick up and run by both my kids and my granny and often it is anticipatory.

Also some of the in play tutuorials are great.

The best games are those like tennis with a clear mapping of real action to virtual action - some of the other games appear somewhat arbitrary (but that doesn't stop my sons exploration and enjoyment).

link|flag
1

Ok, so the question asked about sites. If we can expand beyond that, the Palm Pre gets my vote. I can't really think of any complaints about this phone, it's so very intuitive and delivers a great UX.

The touch screen gestures are quite natural. When friends have picked up my phone to play with it, they all seem to enjoy it.

Boring things like adding contacts to the phone are great: simply pick the source, Gmail, Facebook, etc... and it imports and syncs your contact list. No hassle about having contacts saved on a SIM card.

I happen to use Gmail with it. It's so painless to take a photo, and attach it to an email, even if you've already started a draft. The flow anticipates exactly what I want/expect to happen.

link|flag
only problem is that it's just to slow IMHO – ThomPete Jan 19 at 16:31
the question actually asks about best UI not specifically sites - but re-reading it I can see it is confusing - sorry – Jon Dodd Jan 21 at 10:31
1

WeightBot anyone? I love it!

link|flag
1

Writeroom for Mac does everything a good UI should do, nothing more.

link|flag
1

The best in my opinion is MacOS 10.6. ( think the complexity of an entire OS! )
Also great is NetNewsWire.

link|flag
1

Most of the answers to this question give examples of good UIs.

But from your question it sounds like you also wanted pointers to web sites that aggregate these (a kind of antidote to http://www.baddesigns.com/).

I'd suggest looking at flickr photos tagged usability (this includes some good examples as well as bad examples).

You might also find Dan Lockton's Design with Intent blog useful. Dan shows many examples of good design, illustrating how designers can influence behaviour positively.

link|flag
0

Well most depends on the type of app we're talking about but in general I'm in love with the Things UI and when talking development applications i like Coda and Espresso alot. Especially coda's very elegant svn integration.

link|flag
0

Currency, an iphone app.. simple and easy to check and compare exchange rates at one glance

link|flag
0

Fluxiom: fluxiom.com

Search capabilities are highly intuitive. The bottom bar with icon buttons provides quick and easy access to important components of the interface.

The method of file organization is smart and easy to use.

link|flag
0

win7 w/ only "godmode" on desktop ^^ everything else is winkey+"a few char's" so you get the best out of it ^^

link|flag
Can you explain this a bit more? – sgnewson Jul 26 at 10:52
0

the original version of del.icio.us was sublime. The redesign, unfortunately, is confusing and obtuse.

link|flag
0

Cooliris addon for the firefox has an intuitive interface. Browsing through large quantities of images is a great experience.

link|flag
0

Basecamp - completely intuitive

link|flag
0

One of the best User Interfaces I have used recently is "HOT GLOO" (http://hotgloo.com). It's a prototyping tool, running completely in Flash... and I found it very clean and intuitive.

link|flag
-2

The Social Network I had to have but I always hate to use: Myspace

Myspace and it's crowded pages that make you lose where you are staring at.

link|flag
Hmm. This doesn't sound like "The best UI you have ever used," unless I'm missing something. Perhaps you were looking for this question: uxexchange.com/questions/1390/… – Jeff Van Campen Jan 25 at 23:39

Your Answer

Get an OpenID
or

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.