2

1

This new product is like a meteor that hit everyone I know. What is it? Is it good? Do I like it, do I hate it?

I blogged briefly about it, but it's overwhelming in it's implications.

What are your User Experience thoughts of Google Buzz?

Some topics:

  1. Privacy
  2. First impressions
  3. Implications to Twitter (140 character limit)
  4. Predictions
  5. Whatever :)
flag

7 Answers

4

Privacy: http://news.cnet.com/8301-31322_3-10451428-256.html

link|flag
4

Greatest feature of Google Buzz:

alt text

Image is from: http://www.metro.co.uk/tech/812817-how-do-i-turn-off-google-buzz

link|flag
Not quite: downloadsquad.com/2010/02/12/… – Alastair J Feb 15 at 9:41
Yeah, but it's the best we have, at least for a few days until they actually let you turn it off for real. It's coming as a feature soon (which will be the new best feature once it is available). Check out socialmediaseo.net/2010/02/13/… – Charles Boyung Feb 15 at 16:16
Agreed. It should have been feature #0 on their list, however! – Alastair J Feb 22 at 16:29
Found out that you can now remove Buzz completely, but in doing so, they completely gut your Google profile, if you have one. Not sure if that's a bug or a "feature", but knowing Google, I'm guessing that it's the latter until they get enough complaints and then will change their viewpoint and say that it was really a bug. – Charles Boyung Feb 23 at 3:44
3

I feel the same as everyone else. Massive privacy concerns, although anyone using Google apps or services has to accept that everything ends up in their profiling engine. For me and my friends and family (i.e. bunch of 30-40 somethings) there's no buzz and no real need to use it (or want for that matter).

Perhaps we're not the intended user group. The kids these days love this kinda thing - "ooo shiny, who cares if they're barcoding my forehead?" ;)

I wasn't that enamoured with Wave either tbh, but then again, I'm not a collaborative worker. I'm going to stick my neck on the line here and suggest one MIT grad too many?

N

link|flag
2

Regardless of the obvious privacy issues with the product, I think Google made a big mistake when they didn't clearly explain how Google buzz fits in your day-to-day use of social networks. Or, in other words, they didn't explain to twitter/facebook/whatever-else users why and how they should use Google Buzz instead (or with) what they're currently using. Everyone I know (including me) played with Buzz a little before turning it off.

People won't regularly use (or switch to) another product only because it's a bit better. They need compelling reasons to do so.

link|flag
I totally agree. The same applies to Wave. They're expecting people to make quite substantial changes to their online activity without giving enough incentive. – Rob Feb 15 at 8:31
1

I don't understand the point of it. It is trying to look like twitter, while pulling in things from your contacts from all over the place, and it is just a huge mess to look at. I checked it out for about 5 minutes before I gave up completely.

link|flag
Twitter prioritises newest items, not most recently commented-on. Buzz emphasises conversations, in this respect I would say it's more like facebook. – Danny Hope Feb 12 at 10:12
1

Google obviously wanted to use what they already had - your Gmail contacts. However, are those contacts the same people that you'd like to share that information with? Perhaps, but in a lot of cases, no.

link|flag
1

I like the way they went about implementing it. The challenge for new social networks is convincing people to set up new accounts and upload a bunch of content. Buzz requires neither as it hooks into the platforms people already use to share photos and videos etc (which I realise are mainly owned by Google).

As an enhancement to Gmail I quite like it although I probably won't use it a great deal.

I'm more likely to adopt Buzz as a network than I am Facebook as an email service.

link|flag
See, as a user of Google services, I think this is the worst part about what they did. They forced this piece of garbage on me, rather than asking me to opt in, and no real way (still) to get rid of it. – Charles Boyung Feb 23 at 3:45
Fair enough, but the way I see it, they've added an enhancement to Gmail on a separate page that no one has to visit if they don't want to. You don't have to follow anyone or link any of your other accounts. Although admittedly, users did have to actively opt out on initial launch which creates bad vibes. I'm not a massive fan of Buzz, just playing devil's advocate really. – Rob Feb 23 at 9:00

Your Answer

Get an OpenID
or

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.